Argument Source #4

Argument Source #3

Neurosurgeon murdered dog to demonstrate medical device.

1. Briefly (2-3 sentences) summarize the article.
2. Explain the passage's CENTRAL ARGUMENT. What claims does the author make?
3. Find TWO ASSERTIONS that support the central argument. Explain how each assertion contributes to the author's main argument.

Argument Source #2

Animals should not be used for medical experimentation.

1. Some people think that animal testing should be banned. They believe that there are other options available instead of animals. Some people dont see the effects of animal testing. They say that until they find another option animal is the most ethical way.
2. The claim is that animal testing should be banned.
3. Assertion 1: animal testing should be outlawed because it is hurtful and not necessary.
this is the main argument of the article she tries to defend the animals.
assertion 2:

Argument Source #1

Can the use of animals in medical research ever be justified?

1. This article had two different opinions. The author shows the side of someone who thinks it will be justified and someone who doesnt. The person who does says that they are trying to come up with new technology to use instead but until then they have no choice but to use animals. The person that says no states that these animals are given doses that would be harmful to humans. They dont even know if it would work on people so what is the point of ruining the animals lives.
2. The author writes about both sides of the arguement but doesnt choose a side.
3. Assertion: Animals are vital to advancing medicine. The whole part of the article is based around the fact that they think animals are necessary for research.
Assertion:switching to modern humane research will improve the quality and humanity of our science. The argument is how animal research doesnt help and should be switched to humans so you can see the real affect.

Pathos, Ethos, Logos

This represents logos, its giving facts and information.

This picture represents Ethos because they look like they're important and like they have authority in what they are doing. People Respect them in what they do.

This picture represents Pathos because it makes you feel emotional and helpless for the little girl. She looks homeless and scared and it makes you feel like you want to help her but you can’t.